American Express Complaint

Amex Ruins My Credit Score - Blue Credit Card

11
Helpful Votes
Posted By: italianboarder on 6/30/2008

I have been a so-called Amex Cardmember since 1995. back in those days Amex had the best customer service. When I was in college I opened a Blue account and I was given a credit line for $9200, since my credit score was excellent. That was in 1997.

I used my card to pay for college expenses, I have not been late once and always paid more than the minimum amount.

Now every time I have more than $500 available credit American Express will reduce my credit limit to the total amount owed so that my card looks maxed out. This is affecting my credit score dramatically because it is in good part based on how much credit available you have. I tried to explain this to Customer Service and even to a manager who, in few words, told me it really wasn't any of their problem and thank you for being a loyal cardmember for 13 years (I even had a Platinum card at a time, which I closed since I had little use for it and it was wasteful to pay $400/year just to have it). I sent a letter in April 2008 explaining what they were doing to my credit score and never got a reply. Meanwhile I kept making my payment and since last March I accumulated again another $600 available credit to find out, today, that they have reduced my limit again so my card, once again, looks maxed out in my credit report (this is the 4th time they do it).

Why are there no laws in the US, unlike the European Union, to protect consumers from this kind of practices? In Italy any interest rate over 12% is considered illegal and falls under the extortion law.
As soon as my card is paid off I will close my Amex account and I don't want to hear from them again. So much for being a "great cardmember" who has always paid on-time, before the due date actually, and more than the minimum due.


Update: July 13 2008

Guess what? I just got a letter from Amex, they did it again.
In 4 months I built another $600 available credit and they cut the limit so my card now has $0 available credit.


1 | 2   Next Page >

Next American Express Review >>>



Related Sponsor Links:


Did you find this review helpful?     Very Helpful     Not Helpful


American Express Reviews By Product:

Got something to say? Help other consumers by sharing your experiences on My3cents...



Community Tools:

  • Read comments (7)
  • Consumers: Add your 3 cents to this review!
  • Business Owner? Post your company response!
  • Write a review on this company
  • More reviews on this company


  • Related reviews:

    More reviews on American Express:



    advertise here





    User Discussion - Add your 3 cents!


    sherdy (07/01/2008)      
    Just so you know, when anyone runs a credit check on you, they get a list of what you have and had in regard to credit, if you have been late (it's listed 30, 60 90 days and has an X by the number of days if you have been late). The card may be lowering your number, but the number isn't the bottom line. If you always pay on time, you are good to go. If I were you, though, I'd drop the card. I don't mess with people who want to mess with me. Slamming the door on them is the only thing they understand.

    spamfighter (07/01/2008)      
    Close it NOW and pay it off.

    KenPopcorn (07/01/2008)      
    Lowering your available credit does not harm your score, in fact, it likely raises it. A major part of your score is determined on how much available credit you have, the more you have, the greater risk you are. From the creditor's point of view, you could have $100k in available credit, then get laid off, and max out all that credit with no ability to repay. So having a lower available amount, with a good payment history, actually raises your score.
    Times are tough, and the credit card companies are all starting to limit their exposure to loss.

    quickstep (07/01/2008)      
    Sorry Ken, you are incorrect.

    One of the most widely circulated credit card myths is that lowering the credit limit (or closing an acct) increases the score. It's FALSE. Available credit plays a factor but not nearly as much as % utilization, hence lowering a credit limit ALMOST ALWAYS will lower one's credit score by increasing % utilization. I cringe every time I see this urban legend propagated.

    Similarly, because length of credit history with an issuer is also weighed heavily, any "advice" to close an account can be extra harmful in addition to increaseing % utilization.

    I highly recommened everyone google "credit scoring my... more >>

    Sparticus (07/01/2008)      
    I heard something similar as quickstep is stating. I believe it was on the Suzi Orman Show. She was saying how the length of time you have a credit card is very important to your credit score. So just because you have an inactive card with a high limit, don't close it necessarily. It may end up hurting you more than helping since you are eliminating credit history which is needed for your score. A vicious circle.

    italianboarder (07/06/2008)      
    Sorry, Ken, I agree with quickstep, you are incorrect.
    Lowering your available credit "might" increase your credit score but only in very limited situations, in most cases it will harm your score because the debt to available credit ratio increases therefore showing that you are using most of your available score. Unfortunately the system used by credit report agencies allows for all kind of negative information but is very limited to the amount of positive information evaluated. For example I paid my truck loan 6 months in advance but it did not benefit my score.

    InShock (10/16/2009)      
    The same has happened to me over the last 18 months, as soon as I had a decent amount of "available credit" on Amex Blue, they cut the limit to just above the amount outstanding. Ecery time this happens the explanation is "because of a report from Experian citing too high utilization of available credit". The first time it happened was when an "online retailer" mistakenly entered my account number in instead of their customer, for a purchase of over $5000.00 when I challenged it the cancelled the card (for security reasons) and issued a new one. Amex said they would write to the retailer and if the retailer accepted their mistake then my acco... more >>


     Add your 3 cents!




    American Express Tools & Resources:

    Company Rating:StarHalf starEmpty starEmpty star  (1.5 out of 4 / 632 votes)
    How would you rate this company? Rate 1 star Rate 2 stars Rate 3 stars Rate 4 stars
    View company contact info
    Compare ratings of other companies in this industry
    American Express Consumer Report Overview


    Browse more reviews in category Financial or subcategory Banks/Credit Cards



       Consumer Marketplace       

    Get Firefox!



    Consumer Tools | My Account | Write a Review | Compare Company Ratings | Company Contact Directory | Local Reviews
    Businesses: Respond to Consumers | Product Recalls Directory from Google | Consumer News & Recall Info from Yahoo
    HOME | FAQ | Advertise | About Us | Site Rules | Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy | Press | Site Map | RSS


    Copyright 2000-2010 My3cents, LLC     Browse in another language