Budget Rent-A-Car Complaint

Budget Ireland SCAM cost me $1800!!! - HOW TO GET MONEY BACK - Car Rental

2
Helpful Votes
Posted By: Ashley82MS7 on 6/29/2009

Location: Dublin Ireland

In May 2009, I had a troubling experience in Ireland (apparently notorious for scamming tourists). I have fought for six months and I have WON! Here's my story and here's how to defeat these common scams.

I rented a car from the Dublin airport, a gray VW Golf, and it was acting funny from the start.

It stalled when the clutch was almost fully depressed and the gears would grind even when the clutch was fully depressed. At first I dismissed the stalling as learning a new cars behavior. But after only driving the vehicle for 9km (5.5 mi), the clutch burnt out leaving me stranded. Keep in mind I have years of experience on a stick shift as it was the first car I learned how to drive. I filled out an incident report and was told I would be contacted within days if there were any issues. I left Ireland for the USA 16 days later. Six weeks after THAT, I received a bill in the mail. They had already charged my credit card $1801.13!!! This included towing the vehicle from Dublin (country capital) to Galway (~200 km) along with labor, parts, and a "loss of car hire" fee of 88 euro. Even insurance companies get to assess damage before paying. Why wasn't I afforded this opportunity? I was never given a copy of my own statement, OR a copy of the investigation report concluding I was at fault. I was never even notified they were holding me liable or given information regarding where and when the vehicle was being repaired. There is no way I burned out a clutch in only 9 km and there is no way it should cost almost $2K to repair. Budget of the U. S says they have no jurisdiction. I've filed a complaint to the Better Business Bureau, the Federal Trade Commission, the European Consumer Center, the Car Rental Council of Ireland, and have sent certified letters to the car agency.


1 | 2   Next Page >

Next Budget Rent-A-Car Review >>>




Victory Letter from my Solicitor!
Victory Letter from my Solicitor!


Related Sponsor Links:


Did you find this review helpful?     Very Helpful     Not what I was looking for


Budget Rent-A-Car Reviews By Product:

Got something to say? Help other consumers by sharing your experiences on My3cents...



Community Tools:

  • Read comments (12)
  • Consumers: Add your 3 cents to this review!
  • Business Owner? Post your company response!
  • Write a review on this company
  • More reviews on this company


  • Related reviews:

    More reviews on Budget Rent-A-Car:



    advertise here





    User Discussion - Add your 3 cents!


    Soaring Consumer (06/29/2009)      
    Did you contact your credit card company to see if the charge could be disputed?

    Obviously there was a pre-existing problem with the car before you got it and you should not have to pay for that.

    Ashley82MS7 (06/30/2009)      
    I did call my credit card company about 8 times to talk to 8 different people. The first 7 said I could not dispute that charge. I'm not sure why. Finally the last person I called a week later let me dispute it and issued a "temporary credit" so I'm not sure how temporary it is. I'm not sure what my next step should be or what my rights are considering they are in Ireland. It's been causing so much stress, I just wish it was overwith!

    Soaring Consumer (06/30/2009)      
    Sounds like you need a travel troubleshooter. Christopher Elliott would likely be able to help you.
    http://www.elliott.org/contact/

    Ashley82MS7 (06/30/2009)      
    Actually, I already emailed him last night but received this response this morning: "Thank you for taking the time to write. I'm sorry to hear about this."
    So... not looking good in the help arena. Any other ideas??

    Soaring Consumer (06/30/2009)      
    Hmm... lets see what the credit card company decides, then we can see what needs to be done from there.

    DigitalCommando (06/30/2009)      
    Ashley, try these two links which focus upon Irish consumer relations specifically.
    http://www.eccireland.ie/about_us.html

    http://ec.europa.eu/consumers/redress_cons/docs/ecc_ireland_carrental2008.pdf



    Slimjim (06/30/2009)      
    Like what? I hate to say it, but if the credit card company won't reverse it, it's the end of the line with options.
    Actually i may take that back. Those links are worth trying

    DigitalCommando (06/30/2009)      
    On link #2, page 18, section 3 refers to alternative dispute resolutions and refers to an agency that might help to resolve your issue to a far lower number than $1,800. It's worth a try at least.


    Ashley82MS7 (06/30/2009)      
    Thank you all so much for your comments. I did actually come across those agencies last night after lots of Googling (though not that PDF, so thank you DigitalCommando!). It looks like the ECC is only meant to protect European citizens from other European businesses. I submitted my complaint again today anyway, but it does say "Please contact your local European Consumer Centre if you live outside of Ireland" and if you click the link, the U.S. is of course not listed (http://www.eccireland.ie/about_us/eur_network_list.html). I also did email the Car Rental Council of Ireland last night. I think they might be like the Better Business Bur ... more >>

    turlough (07/09/2009)      
    Funny I had a not-so-great experience with the Dublin Airport Budget people. First, the gentleman rushed through the items for my approval and when questioned gave a vague answer. When I queried the collision damage waiver, he gave me some lame response and said take it or leave it. Fearing the worst, I took it and paid too much. My simplest question to him was to breakdown the insurance package which he didn't. Right after signing for the car and the insurance, I glanced to my left and saw that another customer from the same flight got a similar car but his insurance package was cheaper. Turns out included in my "quote" was coverage of ... more >>

    Ashley82MS7 (07/09/2009)      
    Yeah they seem to use the whole insurance thing to their advantage. I read the 2008 ECC report Digital Commando posted and it says "ECC Ireland recorded that 60% of complaints requiring intervention are against Irish based traders and only 40% against foreign ones." That's ridiculous. It also said "Charges for damages on return form the most problematic category and represent 45% of all car rental complaints received by ECC Ireland. Here, credit cards are charged for damages that the consumer did not cause. In many cases, consumers are not even notified that their credit card is debited and they are not given any chance to clarify the posi ... more >>

    Ashley82MS7 (12/11/2009)      
    For those who said after a credit card denies the dispute you are out of options ... you are WRONG. I hope NO ONE thinks they are out of options. I have been through a lot and here is the fact.
    1. There is NO ONE in the United States that can help you. Not your credit card, not a lawyer, not BBB, no one. So don't waste your time.
    2. It pays to blog. Blogging has allowed me to find Zoltan, another victim of the SAME SCAM one week prior from the same exact place.
    3. You must fight it through the local court system. you WILL WIN.

    Here's what happened. Zoltan found a lawyer ("solicitor") locally to Budget HQ in Ireland. They wen ... more >>


     Add your 3 cents!




    Budget Rent-A-Car Tools & Resources:

    Company Rating:StarStarEmpty starEmpty star  (2 out of 4 / 178 votes)
    How would you rate this company? Rate 1 star Rate 2 stars Rate 3 stars Rate 4 stars
    View company contact info
    Compare ratings of other companies in this industry
    Budget Rent-A-Car Consumer Report Overview


    Browse more reviews in category Travel or subcategory Car Rental



       Consumer Marketplace       

    Get Firefox!



    Consumer Tools | My Account | Write a Review | Compare Company Ratings | Company Contact Directory | Local Reviews
    Businesses: Respond to Consumers | Product Recalls Directory from Google | Consumer News & Recall Info from Yahoo
    HOME | FAQ | Advertise | About Us | Site Rules | Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy | Press | Site Map | RSS


    Copyright 2000-2010 My3cents, LLC     Browse in another language